Brown Shoes with a Navy Suit: Style Guide

Back when I worked on Savile Row, wearing a suit and tie every day was second nature. And even though I was in London where the rules is ‘No brown in town,’ I still loved to wear my brown shoes with navy suits. These days, my uniform looks a lot different. In the past five years, I can probably count on two hands how many times I’ve worn a tie. Just the other day, I put one on—and even though it was a warm day, it felt good to dress up again.

It’s funny how much I’ve leaned into the new wave of casual style, even if I don’t love it. Most mornings, I have every intention to dress nicely, but then reality hits. Between shining shoes, moving boxes, and packing shipments, I usually opt for jeans, an Oxford shirt, a jacket, and loafers or Chelsea boots. It’s practical, but I do miss the days of tailored elegance.

One thing I truly look forward to is stepping away from the day-to-day grind and returning to wearing my beautiful suits—especially my navy ones, which still hang untouched in my closet. I’ve always been a “blue” guy. If I’m not wearing blue, I’m probably in black. But when the warmer months roll in, my go-to look is brown shoes—often suede—paired with a navy suit or various shades of blue trousers and jackets.

There’s something timeless and effortlessly stylish about brown shoes with a navy suit. It’s a classic combination that works especially well in spring and summer, when black can feel too heavy. Here are a couple of looks where I actually took the time to get dressed up—an ode to the style I miss and the one I hope to return to.

The Lighter the Blue, the Lighter the Shoe

When pairing brown shoes with navy suits, it’s generally best to stick with darker shades of brown. Whether you choose suede or leather, the richness of the shoe should complement the depth of the suit fabric. A good rule of thumb: your shoes can be darker than your trousers, but they shouldn’t be lighter.

If you prefer lighter shades of brown, like tan or mid-brown, opt for a lighter blue suit instead of true navy. This keeps the overall look balanced and intentional, rather than mismatched and glaring.

Avoid Tan Shoes, They Are Not Brown

Tan shoes should never be paired with navy trousers—the contrast is simply too stark and undermines both elegance and style. I’ll admit, I used to think differently, but over time, my perspective changed. If you love tan shoes, pair them with lighter options like khakis, chinos, or linen trousers—but keep them away from navy suits.

The only exception where tan shoes work with darker tones is with dark denim. Even then, it depends on the shoe style. A well-made tan brogue or boot can look great with jeans, but that same shoe doesn’t belong under a tailored navy suit. Not even a sleek, brogue-free Oxford can make it work. When it comes to tan shoes and navy suiting, just avoid it—always.

The Mix n’ Match

I love mixing and matching brown shoes with blue clothing—it’s a versatile combination that, when done right, always looks sharp. In the photos, you’ll notice that when I wear lighter brown shoes, I pair them with lighter blue trousers. That’s intentional. Understanding color balance is key: you can transition from lighter to darker tones from head to toe, but rarely the other way around.

One of my go-to combinations—what I call The Swedish—features dark brown suede loafers, tan chinos, and a navy sport coat. It’s a timeless, foolproof look that perfectly illustrates how to incorporate brown shoes into outfits with navy elements without sacrificing harmony or elegance. I do not have a photo of that now, but it is often how I pair things.

Dark Brown Suede Is Your Best Friend

Dark brown suede should be a staple in every well-dressed man’s wardrobe. It’s one of the most versatile shoe colors out there, pairing effortlessly with any shade of blue, from light sky blue to deep navy. This is exactly what the Italians do: they wear dark brown suede shoes with navy suits, and they do it well. Whether it’s loafers, chukkas, or lace-ups, the look is always sharp and sophisticated.

One of the reasons suede works so well is that it absorbs light, minimizing harsh contrast and creating a softer, more refined appearance. That’s also why I prefer wearing bold socks with suede shoes rather than polished leather—the suede tones everything down just enough. If you don’t yet own a pair of dark brown suede shoes, consider your wardrobe unfinished.

Keep It Simple

Don’t overthink it. If you stick to point one and follow the rule about lighter blues with lighter browns and navy suits with darker browns, you will be alright. Just avoid tan and navy. I cannot say that enough. I learned the hard way, stepping outside and immediately regretting my outfit. Just see the images with the brown wholecuts. It doesn’t look good, and I knew that after it was too late.

—Justin FitzPatrick, The Shoe Snob

Shop · Marketplace · J.FitzPatrick · Patreon